## [Scots: Language or dialect?](/en/blogue-blog/scots-language-or-dialect-eng) Posted on July 21, 2025 Written by [Ashley Barnes (About the author)](/en/blogue-blog/scots-language-or-dialect-eng#auteur-author) ![](/sites/default/files/blog_scots-language-or-dialect_376x250.png) You may think the answer is obvious: Scots is clearly an English dialect spoken in Scotland—but is it so cut and dried? When you think of Scots, you probably think of Scottish English. Scots, however, is a separate Germanic language with the same Anglo-Saxon roots as English (Scots: an outline history, n.d.). It has its own grammar, spelling, vocabulary, and idioms. It even retains more Germanic words or forms than English does: for example, **to know** is *ken* in Scots and *kennen* in German. Nevertheless, people continue to question its validity as a separate language—64% of Scottish people don’t even consider Scots to be its own language (Eriksson, 2024). ## Is Scots its own language? Historically, Scots has often been considered bad English by some. The line separating the two languages is blurred, as many Scots speakers use a mix of Scots and English. However, Scottish publications throughout history demonstrate that the rules governing Scots have remained consistent. The grammar of spoken and literary Scots was first systematically documented in the early 1900s. James Wilson’s 1915 Lowland Scotch was based on interviews with Perthshire inhabitants, with responses written phonetically to reflect the dialect. In 1921, William Grant and James Main Dixon analyzed literary Scots over two centuries in Manual of Modern Scots (Young, 2013). In the late 1990s, many authors penned works on prescriptive grammar for Scots in an attempt to make a codified system; 2002 saw the publication of Luath Scots Language Learner, the first Scots second-language course (Young, 2013). These publications provide us with a consistent description of how the Scots language functions. Legislatively, the U.K. government has designated Scots as its own language, and Scots is recognized as a minority language under the European Charter for Regional or Minority Languages (Language, n.d.). But what makes Scots a distinct language? ## What makes a language? How do we determine whether a language is a language in its own right? According to Søren Wichmann from MIT, we have two options: measuring mutual intelligibility or measuring differences between languages (Wichmann, 2019). The first method is problematic. For one, there are different levels of mutual intelligibility. Language B speakers may understand Language A speakers better than Language A speakers understand Language B speakers. This is common in cases where Language A is more widely used; Language B speakers would have more exposure to it. (Wichmann, 2019) Languages can also share a linguistic origin but diverge over hundreds of years. We identify Swedish, Danish, and Norwegian as being three separate languages—yet they are all mutually intelligible (Finnish dances to the beat of its own drum) (Toft, n.d.). The second approach involves measuring the differences between the dialects and languages. What separates Scots from English? How are they the same, and how are they different? Dr. Sadie Ryan points out that they do share a lot of vocabulary, but Scots also has many words of its own. In English, you might say “I worry,” but in Scots, you would say *A fash*. In Scotland, you might also hear *fae* instead of **from** or *leid* instead of **language**. Different vowel sounds are also common. For example, **I have a dog** could sound like *Ah hae a dug*. (Ryan, n.d.) Scots even has some false cognates: You might think the Scots verb *greet* means “to greet,” but it actually means “to cry,” whereas the Scots verb *cry* means “to call” (Young, n.d.). ## And what about grammar? I think the real determining factor is that Scots also has different grammar from that of English. According to “Scots Language and Culture – Part 2,” a course offered on OpenLearn Create, Scots has some different plural forms. For example, the Scots plural for *that* becomes *thae*, and the plural for *this* is *thir*. Where *this* refers to something close and *that* refers to something far, Scots also has *thon* or *yon* to refer to something or someone even further away. Both languages mostly make nouns plural by adding **s** or **es**, but Scots sometimes uses the older **en** suffix (for example, *ee*, which means “eyes” becomes *een*). Some regional Scots dialects use **er** in some plural nouns (the Scots word *child* becomes *childer*). Scots also has a second-person plural: *youse*. (17.3 Some widespread features of Scots grammar – continued, n.d.) According to the same course, where English would use **n’t** (as in **don’t**) to negate, Scots uses *nae* or *na*: **I can’t** becomes *Ah cannae*. *Nivver* can be used to negate a specific occurrence: **I did not buy it** becomes *A nivver bocht it*. Scots sometimes uses double or triple negatives to add emphasis. In English this would have the opposite effect and cancel out the negative. (17.2 Some widespread features of Scots grammar, n.d.) For the past tense, Scots usually adds **it** ending instead of **ed** (**married** becomes *marrit*). Scots also has a narrative present tense, where all verbs end in an **s**: *We gets aff the train*. This device was used in Chaucer’s texts, but now it’s considered grammatically incorrect in English. In comparison, where English uses **than**, Scots usually uses *nor*: **This one’s bigger than that one** becomes *This ane’s bigger nor thon* (17.2 Some widespread features of Scots grammar, n.d.). Sometimes the grammatical structure of a sentence can be completely different as well: *He michtna cuid no hae duin it* (He must not have been able to do it) (Young, 2013). I’ve only just scratched the surface here. If you’re interested in learning more, I recommend [The Scots Learners’ Grammar (opens in new tab)](https://www.scribd.com/document/117018024/The-Scots-Learners-Grammar-v1-2). Are you inspired to learn more about the Scots language? Or do you have another language in mind? Let me know in the comments! ## Sources View sources- [17.2 Some widespread features of Scots grammar (opens in new tab)](https://www.open.edu/openlearncreate/mod/oucontent/view.php?id=147479§ion=3). (n.d.). Retrieved from OpenLearn Create. - [17.3 Some widespread features of Scots grammar – continued (opens in new tab)](https://www.open.edu/openlearncreate/mod/oucontent/view.php?id=147479§ion=4). (n.d.). Retrieved from OpenLearn Create. - Eriksson, M. (2023, July 31). [Which language is most similar to English? (opens in new tab)](https://www.babbel.com/en/magazine/languages-closest-to-english) Retrieved from Babbel. - [Language (opens in new tab)](https://www.scotland.org/about-scotland/culture/language). (n.d.). Retrieved from Scotland. - Ryan, S. (n.d.). [What are Scots & Scottish English? (opens in new tab)](https://speakingscottish.co.uk/scots-and-scottish-english/) Retrieved from Speaking Scottish. - [Scots: An outline history (opens in new tab)](https://dsl.ac.uk/about-scots/an-outline-history-of-scots/origins/). (n.d.). Retrieved from Dictionaries of the Scots Language. - Toft, P. d. T. (n.d.). [The Nordic languages (opens in new tab)](https://www.norden.org/en/information/nordic-languages). Retrieved from Nordic Co-operation. - Wichmann, S. (2019). [How to distinguish languages and dialects (opens in new tab)](https://doi.org/10.1162/coli_a_00366). Computational Linguistics, 45(4), 823-831. - Young, C. P. (2013). [The Scots Learners’ Grammar (opens in new tab)](https://www.scribd.com/document/117018024/The-Scots-Learners-Grammar-v1-2). ## Disclaimer The opinions expressed in posts and comments published on the Our Languages blog are solely those of the authors and commenters and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Language Portal of Canada. - [Leave a comment](#article-comments) - [Read the comments (0) ](#comments) ## Get to know Ashley Barnes ![](/sites/default/files/styles/medium/public/photo-ashley-barnes.png?itok=yX7K7fuh) ### Ashley Barnes Ashley is an English editor for National Defence with a passion for languages. She holds a translation degree from the University of Ottawa, and she loves language studies, musical theatre, and aikido; she also enjoys translating Victor Hugo’s Les Misérables. She currently speaks French and English fluently, as well as Japanese and German conversationally. ## More posts by Ashley Barnes - [English’s lexical siblings](/en/blogue-blog/english-lexical-siblings-eng) ## Search by related themes Looking for more blog posts on the same themes? Click on the links below to see all the posts on the Our Languages blog that relate to the theme you selected. The search results will be displayed in [Language Navigator](/en/navigateur-navigator). - [General knowledge](/en/navigateur-navigator?search_api_fulltext=-&field_writing_tools=1416&sort_by=views&f%5B1%5D=navigateur_navigator_english_theme%3A464#navigateur-navigator-resultats-results) ## Leave a comment Please consult the “Comments and interaction” section on the [Canada.ca Terms and conditions page](https://www.canada.ca/en/transparency/terms.html) before adding your comment. The Language Portal of Canada reviews comments before they’re posted. We reserve the right to edit, refuse or remove any question or comment that violates these commenting guidelines. By submitting a comment, you permanently waive your moral rights, which means that you give the Government of Canada permission to use, reproduce, edit and share your comment royalty-free, in whole or in part, in any manner it chooses. You also confirm that nothing in your comment infringes third party rights (for example, the use of a text from a third party without his or her permission). Join in the conversation and share your comments! You must have JavaScript enabled to use this form. Your name **(required)** Email address (Example: yourname@domain.com) Comment **(required)** Submit Leave this field blank ## Comments There are currently no comments. ## Related links - [Our Languages blog archives](/en/blogue-blog-archives) - [Write a post for the Our Languages blog](/en/blogue-blog/contribute-contribuer) - [Editorial policy for the Our Languages blog](/en/blogue-blog/politique-policy-eng) - [The Golden Quill: An initiative of the Our Languages blog](/en/blogue-blog/plume-dor-golden-quill-eng) - [Our Languages blog](/en/blogue-blog-index) (home page) - [Contact the Language Portal of Canada](/en/apropos-about-eng#a8) - 1245 views Language English